The clause, in plain terms
Look in the conditions section of almost any Tennessee homeowners, landlord or commercial property policy and you’ll find a paragraph headed “Appraisal.” The wording varies by carrier, but the structure is consistent: if you and the company can’t agree on the amount of loss, either side may demand appraisal in writing. Each side picks a competent and impartial appraiser. The two appraisers pick an umpire. A written agreement signed by any two of the three sets the amount of loss.
That is the whole mechanism. It doesn’t replace the claim, and it doesn’t decide coverage. It answers one question — what does it cost to put this property back — and it answers it with a signature that both sides have already agreed to live with.
What we handle once you appoint us
- Deadline check. Many policy forms give each side 20 days after the demand to name an appraiser. We read your form, the demand letter and any carrier response before anything else.
- Our own inspection. We walk, measure and photograph the property ourselves. We don’t start from the carrier’s estimate and argue down the margins; we build a scope from what’s actually damaged.
- A priced, line-item valuation. Estimates are written in industry-standard software with pricing for your part of Tennessee — Memphis labor rates aren’t Johnson City labor rates, and the estimate should show that.
- Working sessions with the other appraiser. Most of the dispute usually narrows here, line by line, with photos and measurements on the table.
- Umpire selection and presentation. If items remain open, we help choose a qualified umpire and present the support for each disputed line.
- Award review. Before you sign anything, we make sure the award states replacement cost, actual cash value and any recoverable depreciation clearly, so payment isn’t delayed by an ambiguous form.
Claims where representation tends to help
The best appraisal files are disagreements about scope and price, not about whether the policy applies. Typical examples: the carrier priced six roof squares of repair and you need a full replacement; the estimate replaces one room of flooring that runs continuously through four; a contents list was depreciated as if every item were ten years old; or overhead and profit were left off a job that clearly needs a general contractor.
How we keep numbers credible
An inflated estimate might feel good on day one, but umpires see hundreds of them and discount accordingly. We write the number we can defend with a photo, a measurement or a price source. That is what moves an award, and it’s the only way we know how to work.
Frequently asked questions
Can I appoint my roofer or contractor as my appraiser?
Most policies require the appraiser to be competent and impartial or disinterested. Someone with a financial stake in the repair contract can give the carrier grounds to challenge the award, so an independent appraiser is the safer choice.
Does the insurer have to agree to appraisal?
If the policy contains an appraisal clause and the dispute is over the amount of loss, the carrier is generally bound by it once a proper written demand is made. Coverage disputes are treated differently, and some policies limit appraisal in specific ways.
How long does an appraisal take in Tennessee?
Straightforward residential claims often wrap up within two to three months after both appraisers are named. Large commercial losses, contents-heavy files or panels that need a full umpire hearing can take longer.
